The Fall of AuctionAds?
- 19 Comments
- By Zac Johnson on August 21st, 2007
Since the acquisition of AuctionAds to MediaWhiz, it seems like I now hear less and less about the company. It seems like their ads are still occasionally down, and I was going to write this article a couple hours ago, but was unable to access their site and check my latest stats. My network traffic is down a bit, as that’s what usually happens during the summer… but my AuctionAds earnings aren’t that great either. What used to generate over $1,000+ a month is now just a jumbled mess of stats.
Let’s take a look at this month’s reporting:
The first week of the month was fine on impressions and click tracking… but what happened to the rest of the month? The CTR falls from a .20% average to .01% every single day after. There is nothing consistent about earnings either. It seems like every other day is a dollar day, then pennies the next. My site traffic isn’t changing and I haven’t touched any coding in weeks…
As you can see, this month I have only earned $256.57 with AuctionAds, compared to my previous monthly earnings of $1.691.42 in June and $816.33 in July. Luckily the ad space that AuctionAds is filling it some extra area I have been testing the offer with, otherwise I would be quite concerned with this deep drop in commissions. Unless something updates on their end and shows better earnings, I will pull their ads this month… as almost anything else will pull these numbers or better with the type of volume I’m giving them.
AuctionAds was a BIG Earner during June, but continues to decline.
I’m sure they are still in a transitioning phase, but I was hoping for a much better month with the AuctionAds, now with MediaWhiz in control. AuctionAds is a really great concept and I’ve never had a problem with payment, but if everyone else on the network is seeing these same type of cuts in earnings and ridiculously bad tracking, I wouldn’t be surprised if they lose a good majority of affiliates. Is anyone else seeing these same tracking issues and a loss in earnings?
- Posted in Affiliate Marketing
"With great power comes great responsibility".... my Uncle Ben told me that. Haha, just kidding! I'm Zac Johnson and I've been making money online for over 10 years now. In short, I started making money online while I was in high school... but my passion for marketing and making money goes back way earlier than that. I created ZacJohnson.com to help motivate you to start making money online, and live the life the you always dreamed of.
Amazing Zac,
I’m not a super affiliate like you (yet), but I too have noticed a decline. It’s true. I can’t say that it’s because of the acquisition but certainly around that time frame I have noticed a decrease. I don’t want to give up on them because it is a unique ad system but if I can’t see the $$$ I might be forced to replace their slots.
Cas
ReplyI dumped AuctionAds awhile ago and since the sale it does seem like its been going downhill fast. I wonder if they have any improvements on the way.
ReplyIam running AA to and its been slow..
do you know if AA has a 30 day cookie
ReplyA new personalized service http://www.blogtions.com has just opened up. Unlike other affiliate programs they will personally tailor adds to your blog. They take a fee, but it’s definitely worth it considering they do all the work for you.
ReplyIt has been a struggle with Auction Ads lately. I began replacing the ads with CJ/Ebay ads and I hate it. I don’t like the layout of the Ebay ads or the time it takes to create them. The last two days have been better with Auction Ads with them creeping back over CJ/Ebay in total commissions on less clicks.
ReplySad to see this. I thought it was just my mediocre blog and low traffic that made my expereince with AA and absolute buts. Eeven at “penny per click” rates AdSense does much, much better.
The AA server setup had acouple issue. I emailed Jermey ages ago, long before the sale, and pointed out what I know from inexperience was wrong … not even a “yeah thanks” message in reply. The server is down a huge proportion of the time .. as you are finding out … and the ads often fill/remder very slowly, hurting traffic and the overall user experience. If they don’t deal with this … and it’s fixable … the service is dead in the water. Sad, because the concept is great.
ReplyI have seen exactly the same thing, I posted about it here - AuctionAds Taking a Big Turn for the Worse?
I am curious, what are you replacing them with? I liked them because they made me money in a banner spot that previously made very little.
ReplyI figured that Auction Ads may start to really suffer as soon as Shoe sold his portion of the business.
ReplyI have far smaller numbers but the same pattern:
June: $16.83
July: $7.82
August: $0.97
Very disappointing after a promising start.
ReplyI got AuctionAds off my blog a while ago, when rumors came shoe is selling, i did not know that the drop was so huge~
ReplyWe went from making $150 two months ago to $8.30 so far this entire month. That’s a huge drop and our traffic is still just as high. We’re scaling AA way back as it’s just taking up space at this point.
ReplyI’ll post my results, I hope that as the word gets out there they fix the problems. I like the network, I like the idea, I like everything about it except the unreliability and the widely fluctuating revenue.
First full month
June - $5529 - 61000 clicks - 5.2M impressions
July - $2900 - 40000 clicks - 5.2M impressions
August so far - $1700 - 23000 clicks - 3.4M impressions
As you can see, things have definitely gotten worse.. even on the same traffic levels. I believe they are missing a lot of clicks and revenue in their reporting. You just can’t do that when you are dealing with peoples money.
Replyyes it does have a 30 day cookie
ReplyI made some good money at the start but after july I didnt change a thing and even though I still get clicks not a cent, Im hopefully that mediawhiz will fix the problems
ReplyI have about the save average revenue per click (about) 4 cents. but earnings are down. There tracking sucks!
I will give them a couple more weeks before I move back to CJ.
ReplyI am seeing the exact same since 8/7. CTR down to .02% and pretty much $0 earnings. I was doing around $100/mo before this.
Reply[...] Johnson is decrying the fall of AuctionAds. I’ve been running AuctionAds on this blog for a little while and I have noticed a bit of a [...]
[...] few days ago I wrote the post, "The Fall of Auction Ads?"… which received a unanimous response from unhappy AuctionAds affiliates. The post was a [...]
[...] I read stuff like this from Zac Johnson, a personal friend of mine who I KNOW makes money hand over fist online, it really seems to [...]