Best Pillow Protectors (2026)
Pillow protectors extend the life of your pillows while creating a barrier against allergens, dust mites, and moisture. Whether you need waterproof protection or breathable cotton, these are the best options for every need and budget.
In a hurry? The Utopia Bedding Waterproof Protectors are the best pillow protectors for most people. Need something more breathable? Go with the National Allergy AllerSoft. Want premium quality? The Brooklinen Pillow Protectors are worth the upgrade.
| Product | Best For | Key Feature |
|---|---|---|
| Utopia Bedding Waterproof | Best Overall | TPU coating, bed bug proof |
| Amazon Basics Pillow Protector | Best Budget | Under $10 for 2-pack |
| Brooklinen Pillow Protectors | Best Premium | 500 thread count cotton sateen |
| National Allergy AllerSoft | Best for Allergies | AAFA certified, 300 TC cotton |
| AllerEase Pillow Protector | Best Temperature Balancing | Moisture wicking, cooling |
| SafeRest Premium Encasement | Best for Bed Bugs | 360° zippered encasement |
| LINENSPA Pillow Protector | Best Value Pack | Affordable 4-pack option |
| Coop Home Goods Protector | Best for Adjustable Pillows | Fits shredded foam pillows |
What to Look For
- Material — Cotton breathes best; polyester is durable and affordable; TPU/membrane backing adds waterproofing
- Closure Type — Zippered encasements offer full protection; envelope style is easier but leaves opening
- Waterproofing — Essential for children, elderly, and allergy sufferers; look for TPU rather than vinyl for breathability
- Allergen Barrier — AAFA certification confirms true allergen protection; tight weave blocks dust mites
- Noise Level — Some waterproof protectors crinkle; premium options use quiet membranes
- Care Instructions — Machine washable is essential; check dryer compatibility and temperature limits
Best Pillow Protectors
Utopia Bedding Waterproof Pillow Protectors — Best Overall
- Pillow Protectors Set of 2: These pillow protectors are tailored to fit Queen-sized pillows, each measuring 20 x 28 inches. (Please note, this set includes pillow covers only, not the pillow inserts.)
- Polyester Knitted Jersey: This fabric provides great comfort and features a TPU coating on all sides to make it waterproof.
- Zippered: A premium zipper and double-hemmed stitching keep your pillow securely enclosed and protected.
- Easy Care: Machine wash gently with the waterproof lining facing inward and tumble dry on low heat. Avoid ironing, bleaching, or dry cleaning.
- Bed Bug Proof Pillow Covers: The high-quality zipper completely encloses the pillow, offering strong protection against bed bugs. (Packaging may slightly vary)
The Utopia Bedding Waterproof Protectors combine effective protection with breathability at an accessible price point.
These zippered encasements feature a soft polyester knit jersey top backed by a TPU (thermoplastic polyurethane) waterproof membrane that blocks liquids, dust mites, and bed bugs while remaining breathable. The zipper closure provides 360-degree protection, sealing your pillow completely from allergens and pests. Machine washable and dryer-safe construction makes maintenance simple. Sold in convenient 2-packs for standard, queen, or king pillows.
Pros:
- TPU membrane is waterproof yet breathable
- Full zippered encasement blocks bed bugs
- Soft jersey top feels comfortable
- Machine wash and dry safe
Cons:
- May feel slightly warm for hot sleepers
- Zipper can snag if not careful
Best for: Anyone wanting comprehensive protection at a reasonable price, especially allergy sufferers and families.
Amazon Basics Pillow Protector — Best Budget
No products found.
Amazon Basics delivers reliable pillow protection at under $10 for a 2-pack, making it the most affordable option available.
These simple but effective protectors feature a soft microfiber polyester shell with a polyurethane backing that guards against dust mites and allergens. The zippered closure keeps protectors securely in place, and the quiet construction won’t disturb sleep. Machine washable for easy care, these protectors work well for guest rooms, children’s beds, and anyone wanting basic protection without premium pricing.
Pros:
- Extremely affordable price
- Quiet, no crinkle sound
- Zippered closure stays secure
- Machine washable
Cons:
- Not fully waterproof
- Basic construction
Best for: Budget-conscious buyers, guest bedrooms, and those needing basic dust mite protection.
Brooklinen Pillow Protectors — Best Premium
No products found.
Brooklinen Pillow Protectors offer hotel-quality 500 thread count cotton sateen with antimicrobial treatment for discerning sleepers.
These premium protectors feature a luxurious 500 thread count long-staple cotton sateen shell that feels silky against your pillowcase rather than plastic-y. The fabric includes antimicrobial treatment to resist bacteria and odors. A hidden zipper closure provides full protection while maintaining a smooth appearance. Brooklinen backs these with their 365-day return policy for risk-free purchase.
Pros:
- Luxurious 500 TC cotton sateen
- Antimicrobial treatment
- Hidden zipper for smooth finish
- 365-day return policy
Cons:
- Premium price point
- Not waterproof
Best for: Those prioritizing sleep quality and comfort over waterproofing, and luxury bedding enthusiasts.
National Allergy AllerSoft Pillow Protector — Best for Allergies
No products found.
National Allergy AllerSoft protectors earn AAFA certification for proven allergen blocking, making them the choice for serious allergy sufferers.
These 100% cotton protectors with 300 thread count construction are certified by the Asthma and Allergy Foundation of America (AAFA) as an effective barrier against dust mites, pet dander, and other allergens. The tight weave blocks particles without waterproof coating, maintaining maximum breathability. Zippered closure ensures complete protection, and the cotton construction stays cool throughout the night.
Pros:
- AAFA certified allergen barrier
- 100% cotton for breathability
- 300 thread count quality
- No plastic or coating
Cons:
- Not waterproof
- Higher price than basic options
Best for: Allergy and asthma sufferers who need certified protection without waterproofing.
AllerEase Pillow Protector — Best Temperature Balancing
No products found.
AllerEase temperature-balancing protectors actively wick moisture and regulate heat for hot sleepers who also need allergy protection.
These protectors feature moisture-wicking fabric that pulls sweat away from your head and neck while allergen-blocking construction keeps dust mites at bay. Allergist recommended for effectiveness, the breathable design prevents the heat buildup common with waterproof protectors. The zippered closure provides complete coverage, and the soft polyester shell remains comfortable against pillowcases.
Pros:
- Moisture wicking keeps you cool
- Allergist recommended
- Breathable non-waterproof design
- Soft comfortable fabric
Cons:
- Not waterproof
- May not block all allergens
Best for: Hot sleepers with mild allergies who prioritize temperature regulation over waterproofing.
SafeRest Premium Pillow Encasement — Best for Bed Bugs
No products found.
SafeRest Premium encasements provide laboratory-tested bed bug protection with their proprietary Micro-Zipper closure system.
Designed specifically to block bed bugs, these encasements feature SafeRest’s patented Micro-Zipper with Velcro seal that prevents even the smallest pests from entering or escaping. The cotton terry surface with polyurethane backing is completely waterproof while remaining breathable and noiseless. Lab-tested and proven effective, these protectors are essential for bed bug prevention and post-treatment protection.
Pros:
- Lab-tested bed bug proof
- Micro-Zipper with Velcro seal
- Waterproof yet breathable
- Noiseless cotton terry surface
Cons:
- Higher price for bed bug protection
- Thicker than standard protectors
Best for: Anyone dealing with bed bugs, prevention in high-risk areas, and travelers.
LINENSPA Pillow Protector — Best Value Pack
No products found.
LINENSPA offers excellent value with multi-packs that protect all your pillows at a fraction of individual pricing.
These smooth polyester protectors block dust mites and allergens while providing basic waterproof protection. The zippered closure keeps everything sealed, and the quiet fabric won’t crinkle during sleep. Available in money-saving 4-packs, these protectors work well for outfitting entire households or keeping spares on hand for easy rotation during washing.
Pros:
- Excellent multi-pack value
- Quiet, smooth fabric
- Basic waterproof protection
- Machine washable
Cons:
- Basic construction
- May not block all bed bugs
Best for: Families needing to protect multiple pillows affordably, and those who prefer rotating protectors.
Coop Home Goods Pillow Protector — Best for Adjustable Pillows
No products found.
Coop Home Goods designs their protectors specifically to fit adjustable shredded memory foam pillows without compromising loft.
Unlike standard protectors that can compress adjustable pillow fill, Coop’s Lulltra fabric (polyester blended with bamboo-derived viscose rayon) stretches to accommodate varying pillow shapes and densities. The breathable, moisture-wicking fabric keeps you cool while protecting against dust mites. The zippered closure provides full coverage, and the hypoallergenic construction suits sensitive sleepers.
Pros:
- Designed for adjustable pillows
- Lulltra fabric stretches with fill
- Bamboo-derived breathability
- Hypoallergenic construction
Cons:
- Not waterproof
- Higher price per protector
Best for: Owners of Coop or similar adjustable shredded foam pillows who need compatible protection.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the best pillow protector for most people?
The Utopia Bedding Waterproof Protectors offer the best combination of protection, breathability, and value. Their TPU membrane blocks liquids and allergens while the jersey fabric stays comfortable, all at an affordable 2-pack price.
How much should I spend on pillow protectors?
Budget protectors run $5-10 per pair and provide basic dust mite blocking. Mid-range options at $15-25 add waterproofing and better materials. Premium protectors at $30-50 offer luxury fabrics and certifications like AAFA.
Do I really need pillow protectors?
Yes, pillow protectors significantly extend pillow life by blocking sweat, oils, and skin cells that break down pillow fill. They also create barriers against dust mites, which affect roughly 20 million Americans with allergies. The small investment pays off in pillow longevity and healthier sleep.
What is the difference between waterproof and water-resistant pillow protectors?
Waterproof protectors have membrane backing (TPU or polyurethane) that completely blocks liquids. Water-resistant protectors repel small amounts of moisture but can soak through with significant spills. Choose waterproof for children, incontinence, or droolers.
How often should I wash pillow protectors?
Wash pillow protectors every 1-2 months with regular use, or immediately after spills. More frequent washing is recommended for allergy sufferers. Most protectors are machine washable—check care labels for temperature limits and drying instructions.
Can pillow protectors stop bed bugs?
Only fully zippered encasements with sealed zipper closures can stop bed bugs. Standard protectors may slow them but won’t provide complete protection. SafeRest Premium and similar encasements are lab-tested to trap and exclude bed bugs.
Do pillow protectors make noise?
Some waterproof protectors crinkle due to their plastic backing. Premium options use quiet TPU membranes or fabric treatments that eliminate noise. Cotton and jersey protectors are naturally silent. Check reviews for noise complaints before purchasing.
What pillow protector material is best for allergies?
100% cotton with tight weave construction (300+ thread count) blocks allergens while remaining breathable. AAFA-certified options like National Allergy AllerSoft provide laboratory-confirmed protection. Avoid vinyl backings which can off-gas and irritate sensitivities.
Should pillow protectors go under or over pillowcases?
Pillow protectors go directly on the pillow, under your pillowcase. This creates a sealed barrier against allergens and moisture while your pillowcase provides the sleeping surface you feel. The pillowcase is easier to wash weekly while protectors need less frequent cleaning.
Do pillow protectors change how my pillow feels?
Quality protectors minimally affect pillow feel. Thin cotton protectors are nearly unnoticeable. Waterproof protectors may add slight firmness and reduce breathability. Premium options like Brooklinen actually improve the feel with their silky fabric. Avoid thick or stiff protectors that dramatically change pillow comfort.
Related Guides
Verdict
The Utopia Bedding Waterproof Protectors are the best pillow protectors for most people because they combine effective waterproof and allergen protection with breathable TPU backing at an affordable 2-pack price. The zippered encasement design blocks bed bugs and dust mites completely.
For those prioritizing breathability over waterproofing, the National Allergy AllerSoft delivers AAFA-certified allergen protection in cool, comfortable cotton. And if you want the ultimate in quality, the Brooklinen Pillow Protectors justify their premium with luxurious 500 thread count cotton sateen that feels as good as your best pillowcase.
