21 Things We Used to Rent Instead of Buy
Some links may be affiliate links. We may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. View our full disclosure.
There’s a version of the past where everyone owned everything outright and never carried a balance on anything. That version is mostly nostalgia doing marketing for itself.
A huge amount of what filled driveways, closets, and living rooms for decades was never actually purchased. It was rented, sometimes for a weekend, sometimes for years without anyone thinking twice about it.
Renting used to be the obvious move for anything expensive, occasional, or fast-changing. Buying outright was the exception, not the default, and the logic behind that made real sense before goods got cheap and credit got easy.
Some of these rental habits died because the math flipped. Buying a movie became cheaper than borrowing it twice.
Others died because the rental version was quietly a terrible deal the whole time, and it took people a while to notice. A few are creeping back, dressed up as “the sharing economy” like the concept is brand new.
This list counts down 21 things that used to be a rental instead of a purchase, from the mildly inconvenient to the one most people don’t even realize was a rental at all. It closes with the one that might be the strangest example of the entire bunch.
21. Party Tents, Tables, and Chairs
A backyard graduation party or a big anniversary gathering meant a truck showing up a day early with folding tables, matching chairs, and a canvas tent staked into the lawn. Nobody owned forty chairs. Owning forty chairs made no sense for an event that happened once a decade.
This one never really disappeared. It’s still the correct call today, and timing a large event purchase around the right season matters just as much now as it did then.
The takeaway: some rentals were never a compromise. They were just the right answer.
20. Halloween Costumes
Costume shops that popped up every October rented full outfits, wigs, and accessories for a flat weekly fee. A convincing costume was expensive to build from scratch, and a kid’s size only worked for one season anyway.
The rental shop model mostly gave way to cheap mass-produced costumes that cost less than a single rental fee used to. That’s a rare case where the cheaper option actually got cheaper, not just more disposable.
19. Carpet Shampooers
The machine sat by the front door of the grocery store, chained to a display, waiting for someone with a stain problem and a weekend to spare. You rented it for a day, hauled it home in the trunk, and returned it smelling faintly of wet carpet.
Owning one made no sense for a household that deep-cleaned carpet twice a year at most. That math hasn’t changed, which is why the rental kiosk is one of the few from this era still standing in some stores, next to the same kind of durable, buy-it-once thinking behind the household goods that used to be built to actually last.
18. Extension Ladders
A thirty-two-foot extension ladder is heavy, awkward to store, and needed maybe once a year for gutter cleaning or a paint job. Hardware stores rented them by the day, which was the sane move for anyone without a garage built around tool storage.
|
You might also like
29 Forgotten 90s Dinners That Fed a Whole Family for Almost Nothing →
|
This is one of the clearer examples of a rental that was actually the frugal choice, not a downgrade from ownership. It’s still true, and it’s part of the reasoning behind the specific things genuinely frugal people refuse to own outright.
17. Pressure Washers
Same story as the ladder. A driveway gets pressure washed once a year, maybe twice. Renting one for an afternoon covered the entire annual need without the machine sitting in a shed for fifty weeks doing nothing.
Rental prices crept up over the years while cheap consumer models flooded the market, and eventually buying a basic unit outright became the more common path for a lot of households.
16. Chainsaws
A fallen tree after a storm was the only time most households needed a chainsaw, and it needed to be a good one, not a toy version that would stall halfway through a trunk. Equipment rental counters kept commercial-grade saws on hand specifically for that once-a-decade emergency.
Buying a heavy-duty saw for a single storm cleanup was never rational. Renting the right tool for a few hours still beats owning the wrong one for years.
15. Moving Trucks and Trailers
Nobody owns a box truck for one apartment move every few years. The rental truck lot was as much a part of moving day as the cardboard boxes themselves, and the price of gas back to the lot was its own small negotiation with whoever borrowed the truck last.
The takeaway: this is one of the only entries on the list that’s exactly as common today as it was decades ago.
14. Tuxedos
A tuxedo rental for prom or a wedding was practically a rite of passage, complete with a fitting appointment and a return deadline stitched into the anxiety of the whole event. Buying one outright was reserved for people who wore one often enough to justify the closet space.
That logic still mostly holds. A tuxedo worn twice in a lifetime is a rental every time, and the math hasn’t budged much since your parents’ era.
13. Wedding Dresses
Less common than the tuxedo rental, but it existed, especially for families where the budget didn’t stretch to a dress worn once and boxed forever. Rental gowns and secondhand gowns quietly overlapped for a long time before either one had much of a stigma attached.
The category has actually grown since then rather than shrinking. Dress rental and resale are more normalized now than they were, which fits the broader shift toward buying certain big-ticket items secondhand on purpose instead of as a last resort.
12. Skis and Snowboards
For a family that hit the slopes once a winter, renting the whole setup at the mountain made far more sense than buying gear that a growing kid would outgrow within a season anyway. Rental counters at ski resorts were a business built entirely around that math.
This one hasn’t changed at all. Anyone skiing fewer than five or six days a year is usually still better off renting, no matter what decade it is.
11. Canoes and Kayaks
A lake trip meant renting a canoe by the hour from a dock rather than hauling one on a roof rack from three states away. It solved the storage problem and the transportation problem in one move, for a fraction of what ownership would have cost a family that visited the water twice a summer.
| Keep Reading — 16 Ways People Make Extra Money During the Holidays |
Ownership only made sense for people living close enough to use it constantly, which was never most people.
That’s the halfway point, and a pattern should already be showing up. Roughly half of this list rented for pure practicality, gear too big, too seasonal, or too specialized to justify owning. The back half gets stranger, starting with a rental most people forgot was ever a rental at all.
10. College Textbooks
Campus bookstores rented textbooks for a semester at a fraction of the cover price, then took them back before finals so the same copy could be rented out again the next term. It was one of the earliest formal book-rental systems most people ever encountered.
The honest version of this story: rental textbooks were often a better deal than buying used and reselling, but plenty of students never bothered to do the math and bought new anyway out of habit or a tight registration deadline.
9. Baby Cribs and Strollers
Baby gear rental services existed specifically for grandparents who needed a crib for a weekend visit, or new parents who wanted to test a stroller before committing to a purchase that would only get eight months of real use. It also covered travel, since hauling a car seat through an airport was never anyone’s idea of a good time.
This category quietly survives today under a different name, mostly through resale groups and short-term gear-sharing services aimed at exactly the same problem, the kind of workaround covered in a rundown of unconventional money-saving moves that actually hold up.
8. Video Games From the Rental Store
Full-price games were expensive enough that renting one for a weekend to finish it before Monday was a common ritual, complete with the risk of a scratched disc and a late fee that felt disproportionate to the crime. An entire subculture of speedrunning existed purely because the rental clock was ticking.
Digital libraries and subscription game services eventually replaced the physical rental counter, though the underlying idea, access without ownership, never actually went away. It just moved online.
7. Movies on Tape
The Friday night ritual of picking a movie off a rental store shelf is one of the most nostalgic entries here, and one of the most extinct. Late fees were a genuine household budget line for some families, quietly adding up to real money over a year of forgotten due dates.
Streaming didn’t just replace this habit. It replaced it with something objectively cheaper per hour of content, which is rare among the entries on this list. For more on how that specific shift reshaped a whole category of household spending, a handful of things that genuinely cost less today than they used to covers similar ground.
6. Tanning Bed Sessions
Not a physical object, but still a rental in every practical sense: paying by the session or the month for time inside equipment you never owned and never wanted to store in your house. Salons ran entirely on this model, packaging sessions the same way a gym packages visits.
This one hasn’t disappeared so much as gotten quieter, as awareness of the health tradeoffs changed the conversation around it without eliminating the industry entirely.
5. Formal Ballroom Shoes
Bowling shoes get the reputation, but ballroom and formal dance shoes had their own rental counters at studios and event halls, specifically because a shoe worn for one recital a year wasn’t worth the closet space or the cost. The same logic applied to ice skates at public rinks.
The takeaway: rented footwear was never really about the shoes. It was about not owning something used four times a year.
|
Worth It or Not
18 Black Friday Traps (And What's Actually Worth Buying)
|
4. Camera and Projector Equipment
Home movie projectors, slide carousels, and later camcorders were expensive enough that camera shops rented them out for graduations, weddings, and vacations rather than expecting a family to own equipment used a handful of days a year. A good projector could cost as much as a used car.
Digital cameras built into phones eventually made most of this obsolete for casual use, though professional-grade gear rental for actual photographers never went anywhere. It’s still the standard way working photographers access equipment too expensive to buy for one job.
3. Rent-to-Own Furniture
Living room sets, mattresses, and appliances through rent-to-own storefronts let families furnish a home with no upfront cost and small weekly payments. For a household without savings to buy outright, it looked like the only door open.
Here’s the part that doesn’t fit the nostalgic framing: rent-to-own furniture was, and often still is, one of the worst financial products marketed to regular households, with effective costs that can run two to three times the retail price by the time the payments finish. It filled a real need for people locked out of financing, and it did that while charging some of the highest effective rates in consumer retail. Both of those things were true at once, and neither one cancels the other out.
That tension is worth sitting with rather than resolving into a clean moral. It’s part of a longer pattern covered in a look at money advice that sounds solid but doesn’t hold up under real numbers.
2. Rent-to-Own Television Sets
Before flat panels made a television a fifty-dollar impulse purchase, a full-size console set was a serious investment, and plenty of households rented one for years rather than buying it outright. The same storefronts running the furniture programs usually ran the television programs too.
Prices on electronics fell so far, so fast, that the entire rental category mostly evaporated within a couple of decades. Owning one outright stopped being a stretch goal and became the obvious default, which is a rare and genuinely happy ending among the items on this list. It’s also a useful reminder before assuming every “smart” version of an old product is automatically worth the extra money over the basic model.
1. The Telephone Itself
This is the one most people don’t know about, and it earns the top spot for that reason alone. For decades, the telephone sitting on the kitchen wall wasn’t owned by the household at all. It was leased from the phone company as part of the monthly service, and customers had no legal option to buy their own.
That changed with a regulatory shift in the late 1960s that opened the door to independently owned phones being connected to the network for the first time. Before that ruling, the phone itself was never yours no matter how many years you’d been paying the bill on it. You were renting a piece of hardware attached to a wire in your own kitchen and had been the entire time.
The shift afterward happened slowly rather than overnight. Owning your own phone became normal through the seventies and eighties as competition brought prices down and choices up, until the idea of renting a telephone sounded as strange to a new generation as renting a toaster would sound today.
It’s a strange one to end on, mostly because it’s invisible now. Nobody looks at a phone and thinks about the decades when owning one wasn’t even a choice on the table. That’s true of a lot of household habits worth revisiting, and some of the old money wisdom passed down from that era still holds up better than people expect once you actually check the math behind it.
The Rental Era
If none of this stuck, the short version is this: renting used to be the default for anything big, seasonal, or fast to depreciate, and buying outright was the exception reserved for things used constantly. That’s not a bad rule, and it’s one a lot of households drifted away from without ever deciding to.
Some of it came back around as a genuinely better deal, like the shift from renting movies to streaming them for less. Some of it, like rent-to-own furniture, was quietly working against the people using it the whole time. Knowing which category something falls into before signing up is the same skill covered in a look at money habits people wrongly beat themselves up over, and it applies just as well to a rental agreement as it does to a purchase.
For more on how these old habits compare to the ones that replaced them, a walk through what actually filled a typical 90s bedroom and a look at which household items get replaced far more often than they need to be both pick up threads that started right here.
